Augustus Lyons
17 min readApr 13, 2024

Welcome to our review of the Butterball Turkey Fryer!

Get ready to impress your family and friends with the perfect, juicy turkey on the table this holiday season. In this roundup, we’ll be diving into the features and benefits of the Butterball Turkey Fryer, sharing our expert insights, and helping you make an informed decision on whether it’s the right choice for your next turkey feast.

The Top 10 Best Butterball Turkey Fryers

  1. Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Roaster for Delicious Fried Turkey — The Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Fryer — a versatile, 28-quart pot, ideal for roasting turkey or other delicacies, features an aluminum basket and glass lid — a must-have for home cooks!
  2. Safe and Stress-Free Turkey Fryer: The Big Easy Oil-Less Tur — Say goodbye to stress and mess with the Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Turkey Fryer: a safe, fast, and easy way to fry a turkey, thanks to TRU-Infrared technology and minimal cleanup!
  3. 22 qt. Stainless Steel Electric Roaster Oven Fryer for Perfect Turkey Cooking — Enhance your cooking experience with the 22 qt. White Roaster Oven Stainless Steel Electric Turkey Fryer, featuring versatile temperature control and perfect for holiday gatherings and large family meals.
  4. Bayou Classic Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer — Butterball Style — Experience mouthwatering fried turkey and more with the versatile Bayou Classic 32 Quart Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer!
  5. Bayou Classic 44-qt Grand Gobbler Outdoor Turkey Fryer — Bayou Classic Grand Gobbler: The ultimate 44-qt turkey fryer with all the accessories needed for perfect cooking results.
  6. Barbour Butterball Turkey Fryer (3025) — 30 Quarts, Stainless — Experience the ultimate turkey frying with the Barbour 3025 30 Qt Turkey Fryer, featuring a patented poultry rack, 12-in Fry Thermometer, and all-season versatility!
  7. Nuuk Butterball Turkey and Fish Fryer Combo Kit — Savor southern fry experiences with Nuuk’s 30QT turkey fryer and 10QT fish fryer combo kit, featuring a welded steel burner stand, 50,000BTU cast iron burner, and CSA-approved 10PSI regulator for ultimate control.
  8. Butterball XL Electric Turkey Fryer: Stainless Steel, 20 lbs Capacity, Deep Fryer with Detachable Cord — Experience hassle-free frying, steaming, or boiling with the Butterball XL Electric Fryer, featuring a large capacity basket, commercial-grade quality, and easy clean-up with a dishwasher-safe design.
  9. High-Pressure Turkey Deep Fryer with Electronic Ignition and 64-Quart Pot — Create mouthwatering, crispy meals with the 64qt Barton Turkey Deep Fryer, featuring a high-pressure burner and versatile accessories ideal for outdoor cooking adventures.
  10. High-Performance Propane Fryer and Steamer for Turkey and Fish — Creole Feast TFK3001 offers a hassle-free 2-in-1 deep frying and steaming solution for Thanksgiving turkey and seafood, providing 50,000BTU power and precise temperature control for a stunning feast with friends and family.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Reviews

Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Roaster for Delicious Fried Turkey

Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Roaster for Delicious Fried Turkey | Image

The Masterbuilt Electric Turkey Fryer truly lives up to its name. With a 28-quart pot, it’s perfect for fitting in that holiday turkey. The aluminum basket and glass lid make it a breeze to keep an eye on the cooking process.

However, be prepared for a bit of a learning curve when it comes to the controls. Despite that, it’s a solid choice for anyone looking to fry a turkey indoors.

Safe and Stress-Free Turkey Fryer: The Big Easy Oil-Less Tur

Safe and Stress-Free Turkey Fryer: The Big Easy Oil-Less Tur | Image

I recently got my hands on the Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer and I must say, this ingenious little contraption has been a game-changer for me this holiday season. As someone who’s always up for a challenge in the kitchen, this fryer has proven to be surprisingly user-friendly and hassle-free.

What really sets this turkey fryer apart from others is its ability to cook a 16-pound turkey without a drop of oil. Thanks to TRU-Infrared technology, my turkey turned out perfectly juicy and crispy, just like I always envisioned. No more stressing about oil splatters or dealing with a greasy mess.

Another major plus is how easy it is to set up and use. The rotary ignition feature makes lighting the fryer a breeze, and with the removable grease tray, cleanup has never been simpler. And, as a bonus, the package comes with everything you need to get started right away.

However, I do have to mention one downside: the product description suggests a “safe, fast, and easy way” to cook a turkey, but I found that the cooking time was slightly longer than advertised. But all things considered, it’s still a far cry from dealing with a traditional fryer.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for a hassle-free, delicious, and oil-free way to cook your turkey this holiday season, look no further than the Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-Less Turkey Fryer. With a bit of patience and some expertly placed temperature probes, you’ll be treated to a mouthwatering bird that’ll have the whole family vying for leftovers.

22 qt. Stainless Steel Electric Roaster Oven Fryer for Perfect Turkey Cooking

22 qt. Stainless Steel Electric Roaster Oven Fryer for Perfect Turkey Cooking | Image

Introducing the Kitchen White Roaster Oven, an elegant addition to any cooking setup that offers unmatched versatility and ease of use. Made of high-quality stainless steel, it brings a modern and sleek touch to any kitchen setup.

This oven features a full-range temperature control, allowing you to cook at 150°F to 450°F for a variety of dishes like roasting, baking, and slow cooking. Whether you’re hosting a large family dinner or preparing a big holiday feast, it’s designed to handle any occasion with ease. It even helps the novices in the kitchen to churn out a delicious turkey for those special occasions.

The use of this electric oven not only saves your time but also energy and money. Additionally, it’s equipped with a strainer basket, perfect for catching any juices and drippings that may occur during the cooking process.

Despite its impressive capabilities, one potential drawback is its size (22 qt. ), making it better suited for larger cooking spaces or areas that can accommodate it comfortably. Overall, the Kitchen White Roaster Oven would be a fantastic addition to any avid cook’s kitchen arsenal.

Bayou Classic Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer — Butterball Style

Bayou Classic Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer - Butterball Style | Image

As someone who loves to cook outdoors, I’ve had the chance to use the Bayou Classic 32 Quart Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer recently, and it’s been a game-changer for my outdoor cooking experience. The fryer’s capacity was more than enough for me to whip up a big Thanksgiving feast, with room to spare for some side dishes.

One of my favorite features of this fryer by far was its portable nature. It’s been really convenient to pack this up and bring it to my friend’s place for a weekend cookout or even to my family’s cabin for our annual holiday celebration. The fact that I could use it outdoors without any hassle was just the cherry on top.

The fryer also comes with a variety of additions that make cooking a breeze. The thermometer included was a lifesaver for ensuring my food was cooked to perfection, and the flavor injector allowed for some creative seasoning options. The skewers, basket, and lifting rack made it all the more versatile — from turkey to chicken, it could handle it all with ease.

However, there was one aspect I found a bit of a challenge — the cleaning process. The hand-wash requirement was a bit of a pain, especially post-fry, when my fryer was covered in oil and bits of turkey. But alas, a small price to pay for delicious, outdoor-cooked meals.

Overall, I’d highly recommend the Bayou Classic Stainless Steel Turkey Fryer for anyone who loves outdoor cooking. Whether you’re a Turkey enthusiast or a fan of fried chicken, this versatile fryer has got you covered.

Bayou Classic 44-qt Grand Gobbler Outdoor Turkey Fryer

Bayou Classic 44-qt Grand Gobbler Outdoor Turkey Fryer | Image

As a home cook, I’ve been on the lookout for the perfect way to make a mouthwatering Thanksgiving meal. Enter the Bayou Classic 44-qt Grand Gobbler with Basket. This turkey fryer seemed promising, with its capacity to hold a whopping 44 quarts of your favorite meal.

My first impression was the sleek stainless steel pot, which not only looked great but also felt sturdy. Cooking a turkey has never been this easy thanks to the raised boil/steam basket above the bottom for steaming. It made sure my turkey got a perfect golden color on the outside while staying tender and juicy on the inside.

What really stood out was the high-quality perforated poultry rack and lift hook, making handling a breeze. The 2-oz seasoning injector with a stainless needle ensured that my turkey got the perfect seasoning, giving it a burst of flavor.

However, there were a few cons to consider. Manually igniting the propane might be a bit tricky for some users. Also, the fry thermometer is a tad harder to read, making it difficult to maintain the exact temperature required for frying.

Overall, the Bayou Classic 44-qt Grand Gobbler with Basket is a solid choice for those looking for a reliable turkey fryer with maximum capacity. With its high-quality features and ample cooking space, it’s the perfect addition to any budding outdoor chef’s arsenal.

Barbour Butterball Turkey Fryer (3025) — 30 Quarts, Stainless

Barbour Butterball Turkey Fryer (3025) - 30 Quarts, Stainless | Image

As a seasoned cook, I recently decided to upgrade my traditional turkey roasting techniques for a big family gathering and opted for the Bayou Classic 30 Qt Turkey Fryer. With its sleek silver design and impressive 30-quart capacity, it quickly became my go-to for preparing mouth-watering dishes.

My first experience with this fryer was nothing short of impressive. The high-quality aluminum stockpot and sturdy handles gave me confidence in the durability of the product. The patented poultry rack and lift hook made it incredibly easy to handle the heavy turkey, while the 12-inch fry thermometer allowed for precise temperature control.

A key feature that stood out to me was the ability to season the turkey using the 1-ounce seasoning injector that came with the kit. The convenience of having everything I needed to fry a turkey in one package made my Thanksgiving preparation a breeze.

However, one downside I noticed was the potential for the silver coating to boil off, which might have some health concerns. Nevertheless, I found that the fryer performed exceptionally well when used for cooking soups, shrimp, and other hearty dishes.

Overall, the Bayou Classic 30 Qt Turkey Fryer has become my trusted companion in the kitchen, and I highly recommend it for anyone looking to elevate their holiday cooking experience. It’s worth considering the pros and cons, but the convenience and delicious results are well worth the investment.

Nuuk Butterball Turkey and Fish Fryer Combo Kit

Nuuk Butterball Turkey and Fish Fryer Combo Kit | Image

The Nuuk 30 qt. Turkey Fryer and 10 qt. Fish Fryer Combo Kit is a versatile and heavy-duty solution for all your frying needs. Designed with a welded steel burner stand, this fryer offers a black powder coating for durability and style. With a 30-quart aluminum fry pot and 10-quart fish fryer pot, you can tackle everything from large turkeys to classic southern-style fish.

One of my favorite features is the inclusion of a turkey fryer stand and lift hook, providing a safe and convenient way to handle your culinary creations. The fryer also comes with a 5-inch and 12-inch thermometer, allowing you to monitor your fry and achieve the perfect temperature for every dish.

Boasting a whopping 50,000 BTUs, the cast iron burner heats the oil quickly for faster frying. And with the CSA-approved 10 PSI regulator, you can easily control the heat and flame for consistent results every time.

However, I did notice a few drawbacks. The first is that the product appears to be poorly made and not very durable. After using it just a couple of times, I noticed a hole in the bottom of the pot. This is not only unsafe but also frustrating, considering the price point.

Overall, the Nuuk Fryer Combo Kit offers a solid variety of cooking options, but its poor build quality and durability are significant drawbacks. If you prioritize quality and longevity, you may want to explore other options on the market.

Butterball XL Electric Turkey Fryer: Stainless Steel, 20 lbs Capacity, Deep Fryer with Detachable Cord

Butterball XL Electric Turkey Fryer: Stainless Steel, 20 lbs Capacity, Deep Fryer with Detachable Cord | Image

I’ve been using the Butterball XL Electric Fryer as my go-to appliance for frying, steaming, and boiling various types of food for a few months now. This fryer has truly made my experience cooking more enjoyable, and it’s definitely exceeded my expectations.

Firstly, I’ve noticed that the heating element is quite powerful, efficiently frying foods with a consistent heat that locks in the flavors. The extra-large basket is a game-changer, allowing me to cook large turkeys, wings, or seafood boils with ease. I appreciate how easy cleanup is, thanks to the built-in drain valve and dishwasher-safe components, making my life much simpler. Plus, the dishwasher-safe basket and frying basket included are a great bonus, saving me an extra step in the cleaning process.

However, there have been a few downsides that I’ve encountered. Since the fryer’s heating element and its wattage work together, I noticed it takes a considerable amount of time, around an hour and a half, for the oil to reach the desired temperature for cooking. It’s worth mentioning that not everyone on the kitchen counter, but this is something I can work around.

Additionally, this fryer gives off a strong cooking odor while in use, which can be a bit overwhelming in some situations, like making donuts, and lingers for a while after a cooking session. Nonetheless, I appreciate that the electric fryer does not emit smoke or require external propane tanks like traditional fryers do.

Overall, while there are some minor drawbacks, the Butterball XL Electric Fryer has significantly upgraded my daily cooking routines. It’s easy to clean, efficient, and produces delectable meals. I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a reliable and user-friendly fryer, as long as they’re aware of the minor trade-offs.

High-Pressure Turkey Deep Fryer with Electronic Ignition and 64-Quart Pot

High-Pressure Turkey Deep Fryer with Electronic Ignition and 64-Quart Pot | Image

I recently tried out the Barton 64qt Turkey Deep Fryer, and my experience with it was quite interesting. The set includes a 64-quart pot, burner stand, regulator, temperature thermometer, hanger, and a sauce syringe. It’s fantastic for preparing delicious Cajun seafood and turkey dishes outdoors with my family.

One of the features that stood out to me was the high-pressure burner. It delivered powerful flames, ensuring quick and even cooking. I also appreciated the electronic ignition, making the setup process much simpler.

However, there were a couple of downsides I encountered. First, the fuel hose was relatively short at 48 inches long, which made it harder to maneuver around our outdoor setup. Second, I faced some safety concerns, as the product is not CSA certified, and the flame burned a hole in the bottom of the pot.

Overall, the Barton 64qt Turkey Deep Fryer provided a solid cooking experience despite some minor drawbacks. With the right adjustments, it could be an excellent addition to any outdoor cooking enthusiast’s arsenal.

High-Performance Propane Fryer and Steamer for Turkey and Fish

High-Performance Propane Fryer and Steamer for Turkey and Fish | Image

I recently had the chance to try out the Creole Feast TFK3001, a 30 qt. turkey and 10 qt. fish fryer boiler steamer kit. As someone who loves to cook and entertain, I was excited to see how this product would perform in a real-life scenario.

Right off the bat, the assembly process was a breeze — it took me no more than 15 minutes to put everything together. The high-output 50,000 BTU cast iron burner was impressive, providing enough power to handle a heavy turkey or a basket full of fish with ease. The adjustable air control panel was also a great feature, allowing me to control the oxygen or gas consumption for a cleaner and more efficient burn.

One of the standout features of the Creole Feast TFK3001 was its fast and accurate temperature monitor. The 11.8-inch L probe thermometer worked like a charm, providing real-time updates on the fluctuations of the internal oil temperature. This made it a breeze to ensure the perfect frying or steaming experience for my guests.

However, there were a few drawbacks worth mentioning. First off, the turkey holder was a bit flimsy and bent easily after just a few uses. Additionally, the product lacks an automatic safety shutoff, which could be a concern for some users. Lastly, the included fish fryer pot was only suitable for frying fish up to 10 qt. , making it too small for handling heavier tasks.

Overall, the Creole Feast TFK3001 was a solid choice for anyone looking to tackle their next big cooking project. Its powerful burner, fast temperature monitor, and ability to handle turkey and fish fryer duties made it a versatile and user-friendly option. Just be prepared for some minor setbacks, such as the turkey holder’s flimsy design and the lack of an automatic safety shutoff.

Buyer’s Guide

Welcome to our buyer’s guide for Butterball Turkey Fryers. This section will provide you with valuable information to consider when purchasing a turkey fryer for your holiday needs or everyday cooking. Remember, we will not be including specific product picks or external resources in this guide.

Features to Look for in a Butterball Turkey Fryer

When selecting a Butterball turkey fryer, consider the following features to ensure you get the most suitable option for your needs and preferences. Look for the following features in a turkey fryer model: heat settings, temperature control, cooking capacity, materials used, and safety features. These features will help you determine which fryer will best meet your requirements for frying turkey efficiently and safely.

Considerations Before Purchasing a Butterball Turkey Fryer

Before finalizing your purchase, consider several factors to guarantee that the fryer fits your specific needs. Some factors to think about are the space required for storage and use, the cooking surface size, power consumption, and the presence of a warranty. By taking these aspects into account, you can ensure your turkey fryer provides optimal performance for years to come.

General Advice for Using a Butterball Turkey Fryer

To make the most of your Butterball turkey fryer, follow these pieces of advice. Always read the instruction manual thoroughly, wear protective gear when handling hot oil, clean the fryer regularly to prevent corrosion, and never leave the fryer unattended during cooking. These tips will help ensure your cooking experience is enjoyable, safe, and hassle-free.

In conclusion, selecting a suitable Butterball turkey fryer involves evaluating its features, considering your specific needs and preferences, and following general advice for safe and efficient cooking. By carefully considering these aspects, you can ensure your turkey fryer brings you the best results, providing delicious meals for you and your loved ones.

FAQ

What is a Butterball Turkey Fryer?

A Butterball Turkey Fryer is an electric turkey fryer specifically designed for deep-frying a whole turkey. It is manufactured by the same company that produces Butterball turkeys, ensuring that the product is tailored to their meat. The fryer features a sturdy construction, large capacity, and convenient controls.

The Butterball Turkey Fryer is ideal for home cooks who want to prepare a juicy, flavorful turkey without the hassle of traditional oven roasting. It is easy to use, safe, and produces consistently excellent results, making it a popular choice during Thanksgiving and other special occasions that call for a delicious turkey.

How does the Butterball Turkey Fryer work?

The Butterball Turkey Fryer works by deep-frying a whole turkey in hot oil. The fryer has a large capacity, allowing it to accommodate a turkey up to 12–18 pounds in size. The turkey is first seasoned and covered in a special coating before being placed in the fryer. The fryer is then filled with a sufficient amount of oil, and the turkey is submerged and cooked at a controlled temperature until it reaches an internal temperature of 165°F, ensuring that it is cooked through and safe to eat.

The Butterball Turkey Fryer comes with a digital control panel that makes it easy to set and monitor the cooking temperature and time. The fryer also features a built-in thermostat that maintains the oil temperature throughout the cooking process, ensuring consistent results every time. Once the cooking is complete, the turkey is carefully removed from the hot oil, and any excess oil is drained off before serving.

What is the capacity of the Butterball Turkey Fryer?

The Butterball Turkey Fryer has a capacity of 12–18 pounds, depending on the specific model. This allows it to accommodate a whole turkey comfortably, making it suitable for serving a large family or gathering. The fryer is designed to be user-friendly and easy to handle, even when cooking a large turkey.

It is essential to ensure that the turkey does not exceed the capacity of the fryer, as overfilling can lead to safety concerns and may result in uneven cooking. When using the fryer, always refer to the user manual for specific instructions on how to fill the fryer with oil and the recommended cooking times and temperatures for the size of the turkey being cooked.

What is the warranty period for a Butterball Turkey Fryer?

The warranty period for a Butterball Turkey Fryer typically ranges from one to two years, depending on the specific model. The warranty covers any defects in materials or workmanship during the warranty period. If a customer experiences any issues with their fryer, they can contact the manufacturer’s customer support team for assistance.

It is essential to register the product with the manufacturer as soon as possible after purchase to ensure that the warranty is valid. Registration can usually be done online through the manufacturer’s website or by contacting their customer support team. By registering the product, customers will also receive updates on any recalls or safety notices related to the fryer.

What safety precautions should be taken when using a Butterball Turkey Fryer?

When using a Butterball Turkey Fryer, several safety precautions should be taken to ensure the well-being of the user and to prevent any accidents or damage to the appliance. These include the following steps:

  1. Always read the user manual thoroughly before using the fryer for the first time and follow the instructions carefully.
  2. Ensure that the fryer is placed on a stable, level surface and away from any flammable materials, such as paper products or curtains. The fryer should also be placed outdoors, in a well-ventilated area, unless specifically designed for indoor use. 3. Use the recommended cooking oil and ensure that it is not overfilled in the fryer. 4. Wear appropriate clothing, such as an apron and gloves, when handling the fryer and the hot oil. 5. Never leave the fryer unattended while in use, and always have a fire extinguisher or baking soda handy in case of an emergency.

How do I clean my Butterball Turkey Fryer?

Cleaning a Butterball Turkey Fryer is an essential part of maintaining the appliance and ensuring its longevity. After each use, the fryer should be allowed to cool completely before beginning the cleaning process. Once cooled, follow these steps to clean the fryer:

  1. Disconnect the fryer from the power source and unplug it.
  2. Carefully remove any leftover food particles and oil residue from the cooking basket, lid, and exterior of the fryer using a soft sponge or cloth. If necessary, use a mild detergent and warm water to gently clean the fryer’s components. 3. Rinse all components thoroughly with water to remove any soap residue. 4. Allow the fryer to air dry completely before storing it away.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.